The likelihood ratio implies either amplification or attenuation of the prior odds and is as such a measure of evidentiary strength the value of evidence. Explaining the likelihood ratio in dna mixture interpretation. The indicator for low strength evidence was placed as close as possible to the neutral point without intersecting it to reflect the likelihood ratio of 5. In this hypothetical, let us assume it is reported that, given the dna mixture found in the evidence sample, it is 1,000,000 times more probable that the sample originated from defendant 1 and two unknown unrelated individuals, than three unknown unrelated individuals. They can flexibly consider alternate hypotheses and can account for population substructure. Part ii describes an alternate way of presenting dna statistics in court based on bayesian likelihood ratios. These ideas were extended to evidence with multiple contributors. Part i of this paper discusses the issue of what the frequencies associated with dna evidence do and do not mean. It is also used in parentage testing, 2 to establish immigration eligibility, 3 and in genealogical and medical research. The method involves the use of likelihood ratio lr, a statistical tool that gives experts a shorthand way to communicate their assessment of how strongly forensic evidence, such as a fingerprint or dna sample, can be tied to a suspect. The evidence originated from three unknown, unrelated individuals. This book explains the correct logical approach to analysis of forensic scientific evidence. Dna statistics in the simpson matter nature genetics. A practical guide to assigning likelihood ratios will provide a roadmap for labs all over the world and the next generation of analysts who need this foundational understanding.
Nist experts urge caution in use of courtroom evidence. How dna evidence creates victims of chance new scientist. Hence the value v of evidence has to be a function of the likelihood ratio. The likelihood ratio is the probability under hypothesis 1 that the suspect profile and the evidencesample profile will both be x, divided by the corresponding. Incorporating uncertainty into likelihood ratios for dna. Jan 01, 2017 we have written many times before see the links below about use of the likelihood ratio lr in legal and forensic analysis. Likelihood ratios for evaluating dna evidence when the. The advantages of using a likelihood ratio for forensic evidence interpretation has long been recognised by ian evett1. Dna testing and its forensic analysis are recognized as the gold standard in forensic. This approach has gained increasing support especially in the areas of dna and glass evidence interpretation. If you can think of evidence as meaning information that might nudge your decision about some matter in one direction or the other, then the lr is the appropriate numerical summary of the evidence. Dean hildebrand, in forensic dental evidence second edition, 2011. Data from dna test strips are uploaded to a computer and run through an array of probability models until the software spits out a likelihood ratio the.
Forensic dna analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. Jan 08, 2020 again, as described by the national research council, the likelihood ratio is still one step removed from what a judge or jury truly seeks an estimate of the probability that a suspect was the source of a crime sample, given the observed profile of the dna extracted from samples. Statistical aspects of interpreting dna profiling in legal. The greater the likelihood ratio, the stronger is the evidence in favor of the hypothesis corresponding to the numerator, that the source of the evidence sample dna and the suspect are the same person.
Testing likelihood ratios produced from complex dna profiles. The likelihood ratio lr is the recommended approach for forensic dna mixture analysis by the dna commission of the isfg, as it makes maximum use of available data and parameters for allelic dropout and dropin can be incorporated. Contributors to the mixture may come from one or more ethnic groups. The techniques used in forensic dna analysis are based upon the accepted principles of molecular biology. In dna identification science, the likelihood ratio lr assesses the. This technique enables experts to communicate the weight of the evidence with a single number. The indicator for high strength evidence was placed fractionally past the midpoint of the positive side of the scale to reflect the likelihood ratio of 5500. The focus is on general methods of analysis applicable to all forms of evidence. The problem of evaluating this dna evidence in a forensic context, when the suspect is found through a database search, is analysed through a likelihood approach. The likelihood ratio is simply 1 divided by 2 and provides a simple and compelling measure of probative value of evidence. Likelihood ratio statistics for dna mixtures allowing for. Likelihood ratios are necessary to properly interpret mixed stain dna evidence. Unfortunately, minimizing dna evidence leads to a failure to identify. Like the first edition, the book analyses real legal cases and judgments.
A brief introduction to likelihood ratios is given in appendix a. Define likelihood ratios for pairs of hypotheses about the source of dna evidence and compute their magnitudes. Each row of the table lists a possible pattern of gene sharing among child, mother, and alleged father on the left and paternity index formulas on the right. Sherlock holmes and the dna likelihood ratio youtube. Aug 18, 2010 how dna evidence creates victims of chance. Apr 21, 2016 now in its second edition, forensic dna evidence interpretation is the most comprehensive resource for dna casework available today. It is important to keep in mind that methods for reporting dna evidence vary between laboratories. Recall that the likelihood ratio is commonly used as a measure of the probative value of some evidence e for a hypothesis h. Read the evaluation of forensic dna evidence at nap. Use the likelihood ratio to measure the probative value of dna matches and other. The interpretation of dna evidence a case study in probabilities an. The likelihood ratio tells how much the prior odds are changed when the forensic findings are taken into account.
Jan 17, 2017 likelihood ratios explained physiotutors. The evidence originated from john doe and two unknown individuals. The identification process can not advance until the forensic dna analyst has both components available for evaluation. Since there are many alternative possibilities for the source of the dna, a 2 to 1 ratio means the evidence. The problem with the likelihood ratio for dna mixture profiles.
Dna has long been considered the gold standard of forensic evidence, heralded for its ability to exonerate the innocent and convict the guilty. Following bayes rule, individuals multiply their previous or prior odds by their respective likelihood ratios to obtain their updated or posterior odds reecting their revised degrees of belief regarding the claim in question. The evidence increased our belief that the suspect contributed to the dna by a factor of a billion. If the ratio is less than one the evidence e supports hd, with smaller values indicating stronger support. The probability of the evidence if the crime stain originated with the suspect or pres the probability of the evidence. If the ratio is greater than one the evidence e supports hp, with higher values indicating stronger support. Swgdam recommendations for the efficient dna processing of sexual assault evidence kits. The dna profile is at least lr times more likely if it originated from john doe and. Oct 16, 2015 this experiment examined the way that people recruited from amazons mechanical turk n 541 responded to 2 types of forensic evidence a dna comparison and a shoeprint comparison when an expert explained the strength of this evidence 3 different ways. Kai explains in depth how to calculate likelihood rations using equations and the nomogram method.
Dna evidence bayesian networks and probabilistic inference. Addendum to the swgdam interpretation guidelines for autosomal str typing by forensic dna testing laboratories to address next generation sequencing. With these new continuous dna interpretation systems and a new, more powerful, dna profiling kit globalfiler there is an opportunity to reexamine the behaviour of a commonly used statistic in forensic science, the likelihood ratio lr. Dna profiling is a forensic technique in criminal investigations, comparing criminal suspects profiles to dna evidence so as to assess the likelihood of their involvement in the crime.
It starts by explaining the general principles and then applies them to issues in dna and other important forms of scientific evidence as examples. In fact, koehler 1996 found that even when mock jurors were presented with the exact same dna evidence expressed in different notations frequency, likelihood ratio, or posterior odds ratio. Using continuous dna interpretation methods to revisit. Independence of alleles within and between ethnic groups is assumed. Jul 02, 2012 in dna identification science, the likelihood ratio lr assesses the evidential support for the identification hypothesis that a suspect contributed their dna to the biological evidence. Likelihood ratio lr tests are provided for the three alternatives to dna identity.
Mixture interpretation using probabilistic genotyping. Statistical issues the evaluation of forensic dna evidence. The likelihood ratio is particularly well suited for the statistical analysis of forensic dna evidence because, as in a trial, two alternative hypotheses are compared. For instance, a ballistics examiner compares a bullet found at a crime scene to a bullet that was testfired from a suspects gun. Written by leaders in the fields of biology and statistics, including a contribution from peter gill, the father of dna analysis, the book emphasizes the interpretation of test results and provides the necessary formulae in an easily accessible manner. The use of likelihood ratios in reporting difficult. On the interpretation of likelihood ratios in forensic. Among the tools discussed are likelihood ratios and probabilities of weak evidence and strong misleading evidence.
Forensic dna analysis rests on a firm foundation of biology. Should the likelihood ratio be used in the courtroom. But this new generation of dna evidence is far from its established predecessor both in the quality of the evidence collected and the clarity of what is presented in court. E circumstantial evidence search for foreign dna in intimate samples, in many cases, may recover traces of dna of the person who is technically a substrate even if attempts to fractionate the dna are made during the test incomplete differential extracts, penile swabs, etc what constitutes a dna. It has been argued lund and iyer, 2017 that the forensic community view the likelihood ratio as only one possible tool for communication with decision makers. However, there is a great need for a handson stepbystep guide to teach the forensic dna community how to interpret dna mixtures, how to assign a likelihood ratio, and how to use the subsequent likelihood ratio when reporting interpretation conclusions. In evidence based medicine, likelihood ratios are used for assessing the value of performing a diagnostic test. Explaining the likelihood ratio in dna mixture interpretation what is the likelihood ratio. Recommendations of the swgdam ad hoc working group on genotyping results reported as likelihood ratios.
Oct 12, 2017 the method involves the use of likelihood ratio lr, a statistical tool that gives experts a shorthand way to communicate their assessment of how strongly forensic evidence, such as a fingerprint or dna sample, can be tied to a suspect. Intended as a thirdedition companion to the fundamentals of forensic dna typing volume published in 2010 and advanced topics in forensic dna typing. The problems with dna evidence and testing the atlantic. If the lr is 1,000, the probability that the profiles are the same is 1,000 times as great if the samples came from the same person as it is if they came from different persons. For a general exposure to the potential role of probability and statistics in the law, the reader may consult fienberg 20, dawid 21, and kaye and freedman 22.
Likelihood ratios for paternity situations dnaview. In dna identification science, the likelihood ratio lr assesses the evidential support for the identification hypothesis that a suspect contributed their dna to the biological evidence. Data from dna test strips are uploaded to a computer and run through an array of probability models until the software spits out a likelihood ratiothe. Dna testing and its forensic analysis are recognized as the gold standard in. Here is the original form that came out sixty years ago in jack goods book, the. Now in its second edition, forensic dna evidence interpretation is the most comprehensive resource for dna casework available today. We have developed and validated a lr method and software for analysis of mixed evidence samples in which dropout of true contributors. This ratio shows the value of the evidence introduced, indicating which hypothesis the evidence favors. The lr summarizes the sensitivity and specificity of a statistical test. Indeed, the likelihood ratio drops dramatically under the rule except for the cases n 2, m 1 and n 2, m 2, in which the likelihood ratio rises from 3. Interpretation builds upon the previous two editions of john butlers internationally acclaimed forensic dna typing textbook with forensic dna analysts as its primary audience. Interpretation of dna typing results for kinship analysis. Jun 02, 2016 the weightof evidence question comes up anytime a forensic examiner assesses the likelihood that a piece of evidence left at a crime scene originated from a particular source.
This includes modern interpretation methods and contemporary population genetic models available for estimating dna frequencies or likelihood ratios. Dna testing and its forensic analysis are recognized as the gold standard in forensic identification science methods. Lr likelihood 1 ratio the ratio of two probabilities of the same event under different hypotheses. For example, a likelihood ratio can be expressed as an lr of 1,000. Explaining the likelihood ratio in dna mixture interpretation 2 abstract in dna identification science, the likelihood ratio lr assesses the evidential support for the identification hypothesis that a suspect contributed their dna to the biological evidence. In theory, the subjective bayesian framework provides a uniquely rational and coherent 4 approach for an. Likelihood ratios in forensic dna work we evaluate the evidence e relative to alternative pairs of hypotheses usually these hypotheses are formulated as follows. Likelihood ratio lr describes how strongly the genotypes support one relationship versus the other relationship expresses the likelihood of obtaining the dna profiles under two mutually exclusive hypotheses the lr takes into account. Another approach is to report likelihood ratios lrs to convey relative support for the weight of dna evidence. A likelihood approach to dna evidence springerlink. Identification methods comparing a dna profile from unidentified human remains with that of a direct from the person or indirect for example, from a biological relative reference sample and ranking the pairwise likelihood ratios lr is straightforward and well defined. Synopsis dna testing and its forensic analysis are recognized as the gold standard in forensic identification science methods. With new highly sensitive technology, tiny amounts of dna, often just a few. In such forensic areas the scale of the likelihood ratio may be.
Dna typing is an important tool in missingperson identification, especially in massfatality disasters. The paternity index formulas were derived automatically by the symbolic kinship program. When quantifying the results of dna analysis, forensic science experts often use the likelihood ratio. A likelihood ratio compares the probabilities of observing the evidence under two different hypotheses. Nist urges caution in use of likelihood ratio forensic. Likelihood ratios for paternity situations excluding mutation. Although a considerably large amount of papers and books have been. Simpson was acquitted of two murders in spite of very strong dna evidence linking his blood to the crime. The likelihood ratio, then, is a way of summarizing the dna evidence. The interpretation of dna evidence a case study in. Likelihood ratios for evaluating dna evidence when the suspect is found through a database search anders stockmarr department of forensic genetics, institute of forensic medicine, and department of biostatistics, university of copenhagen, 11 frederik vs vej, dk. We have written many times before see the links below about use of the likelihood ratio lr in legal and forensic analysis. After attending this presentation, attendees will better understand the principles of reporting dna match results using a likelihood ratio lr.
Calculates likelihood ratio for dna evidence, comparing two hypotheses about the origin of the mixture at the crime scene. Like other forensic disciplines, a forensic dna analysis is a comparative process requiring profiles from the questioned as well as known source. In a trial, a jury weighs the prosecution hypothesis and the defense hypothesis and determines which is more likely to explain the evidence. Though lindley 2014 makes it clear that the lr in bayes formula is the personal lr.
Confidence interval of the likelihood ratio associated. For the purpose of introducing some of the molecular tools used to classify dna types in court, rflp and pcrbased methods are described. Dna identification by pedigree likelihood ratio accommodating. The likelihood ratio should be seen as an estimate and not a fixed value, because the calculations are functions of allelic frequency estimates that were estimated from a small portion of the population. Alan turing, ushered the lr into mainstream scientific thought with his classic book. In evidencebased medicine, likelihood ratios are used for assessing the value of performing a diagnostic test. Aug 14, 2017 the likelihood ratio and its use in the grooming gangs news story this blog has reported many times previously see links below about problems with using the likelihood ratio. They use the sensitivity and specificity of the test to determine whether a test result usefully changes the probability that a condition such as a disease state exists. To my knowledge, the nc state crime laboratory and the charlottemecklenburg police department do not employ the likelihood ratio in their interpretations of dna evidence, though it could be adopted at some point in the future.
952 1238 1466 932 128 1356 898 1373 647 83 485 392 957 1321 237 878 1176 280 1209 859 1362 648 1116 411 92 1552 1469 595 324 768 1344 1188 1460 1061 1548 769 694 943 667 458 306 1321 1145 84 1409